
A few days ago, for some reason or another, my friend and I decided to make a list of negative qualities our future husbands would have to put up with from us. I don’t know whose idea this was. I’m pretty sure it was mine; my friend thinks it was hers, and I’ve decided to let her believe that. Because it was a terrible idea.
I’m a big fan of lists usually. Shopping lists, goal lists, lists of ways to improve my life, lists of my faults, lists of my physical defects—I’ve made them all, usually several times. My favorite is making to-do lists and then accomplishing nothing on them.
But this was different. It lacked the usual joy I find in mutilating my self-esteem. It kept my friend awake at night. The list just grew and grew, starting with very obvious faults I have to things that could be good or bad, depending on your perspective. For example, I’ve been told I don’t care enough about how I look, and yet I know to some people I’m silly and vain and I care too much. So which is it? Let’s put down both!
I’ve been thinking about why this felt so bad, and in the end I’m glad I did it, because it made me realize a few things. First of all, people are not lists—people are not even qualities. Someone kind and nice may be nothing like another kind, nice person. And no one is always nice. A better way of figuring what someone is would be to ask, “When is this person unkind? And why?”
Do you know how complicated people are? I wonder if they can even be reduced to words. The best people cannot, so I wonder why we would strive to be that simplistic, to diminish ourselves. Self-improvement should mean becoming more, not erasing parts of yourself to be more easily described, to be simpler and less messy. My favorite people are the messy ones. How can anyone with depth bond with someone who refuses to ever be complicated? This is what people want. We want to be fascinated by someone, and for that to happen, we have to wonder about them. There has to be something beneath the surface to discover.
The other thing I realized is that you shouldn’t advertise whatever’s wrong with you. Yes, be self-aware, blah blah blah, but that quality is valuable when you need to admit you’re wrong. So tell people if that’s the case. But don’t pass out a list of all the ways you’ve been wrong all your life. Because they will believe you.
Actions only speak louder than words to people who take the time to look at them. Most don’t bother. If you believe you’re hard-working, smart, likable, beautiful, whatever, other people are more likely to believe it too. If you tell them you’re an awkward spaz, you’ll find shortly afterwards they’re teasing you for being an awkward spaz. And somehow that feels way less funny than it did when you were saying it.
Self-deprecating jokes backfire. If you tell people you’re an idiot, you’re going to start convincing them. After all, wouldn’t you know better than anyone else? It also works in reverse. Maybe I take people at face value more than others do, but I have at times been in the presence of women who either believe or desperately need to believe they are wildly attractive and sought after by most men. And they usually are pretty, just not extraordinary. And I leave thinking, if all these people treat you this way, there must be a good reason. Why doesn’t this happen to me? Are you that much better?
People lie, sometimes overtly, sometimes in little ways without even realizing it. They tell you they are who they wish they were, and we listen. Then there are other people, usually more honest people who aren’t so insecure that they can’t admit their flaws, who tell you what they are trying not to be. And then it becomes their epitaph, or at least their punchline.
Me being the moron that I am, I’m probably not going to stop saying negative things about myself. It’s a hard habit to break; there really is something addictive about it. But the next time someone doesn’t take me seriously, I will know that I might be the reason why.




